Should Rangers have shown more caution with MacLeod & Clark?

Lewis MacLeod, courtesy of RFC

The injury list continued to add some new victims following Rangers draw with Alloa Athletic.

It began with word that Lee Wallace had picked up a calf injury prior to the Raith Rovers match.  He managed to play through the pain last week but Ally McCoist understandably had Wallace sit out this weekend’s match with a League Cup fixture looming on Tuesday.

However, another Rangers star maybe should have been sidelined as well.   On the RangersTV broadcast, it was reported that Lewis MacLeod had picked up a knock on his ankle in the build up to the match with Alloa.  Knowing that MacLeod was not at 100%, he still trotted out against the Wasps.

It is quite normal for players to play with injuries however in hindsight it was a questionable decision to allow MacLeod to play with a bum ankle on Alloa’s artificial surface.  The ‘plastic pitch’ was not kind to MacLeod, who showed that he was in pain early on.  After a few minutes of obvious discomfort he was subbed off in the 13th minute.  Now his status for Tuesday is in doubt.

Another first half injury that was not dealt with right away was Nicky Clark’s shoulder injury.  When Clark picked up the injury it was obvious to anyone watching that he was in a great deal of pain.  However, play was never stopped & Rangers lined up a corner kick within seconds.  Ironically, Clark was called upon to make a play on the ball – even as he was feeling the immediate effects of a dislocated shoulder.

Of course, if a player does not go down to the ground – he isn’t going to get medical attention.  You can’t fault Rangers for not sending a training staff out in that moment, as Clark’s teammates were not aware of the injury.

However, the match went on for a good five minutes with Clark in obvious pain.  Maybe Rangers were just hoping Clark could make it to the half but when a collision with Alloa’s Ben Gordon flattened Clark in an awkward heap – it was difficult not to question why he was still on the pitch.

Nicky Clark, courtesy of RFC

It is a byproduct of Rangers ‘win at all costs’ mentality.  Rangers cannot afford a hiccup – the backlash is severe & the pressure is immense to win each & every match.

It explains why the depths of the squad are very rarely utilized – even when the club faces two matches in four days.

But the question that begs to be asked is why have a player like Dean Shiels on your roster if you’re not going to use him?

If MacLeod’s ankle was not 100% healthy – why send him out on an artificial surface, especially when you have players like Shiels, Arnold Peralta, or David Templeton waiting in the wings?

Jon Daly, courtesy of SNS

A similar issue arose last season when Jon Daly was trotted out – week after week – even when it appeared that his body may be breaking down.  Daly eventually had to have knee surgery to repair the damage done as he soldiered through the pain.

At the time of the surgery, McCoist explained – “Towards the end of the season, we would have given him a little rest if we could have but personnel indicated we couldn’t.”

“With Andy Little injured, he was our only striker at points and, to be fair to him, he kept turning up and playing for us.  He was playing through a little bit of pain then had a good rest in the close season but there is still a little niggle there.”

Yet again, hindsight is 20/20 – but the facts are that Rangers eventually won League One by 39 points while Nicky Clark & Calum Gallagher were in reserve.  Also, as he was dealing with the discomfort Daly scored two goals in the last two months of the season – so it is difficult to contend that his role was crucial to Rangers victories.

Mistakes are going to happen when managing a squad of players.  Footballers want to play & will play through pain.

However, it is critical for the manager to have the foresight to sit a player down when there is a chance he may aggravate a pre-existing injury.  McCoist got it right with Wallace & it likely means he’ll be ready for Tuesday’s match with Falkirk.

Unfortunately, it looks as if he may have shown the same caution with MacLeod.

Scottish Football Stats from BetExplorer

4 thoughts on “Should Rangers have shown more caution with MacLeod & Clark?

  1. There is no way that anyone other than the coaching staff and McLeod himself know how he felt prior to this game.He may have said that he felt okay and playing on this pitch aggravated the ankle again.The priority has to be the league so if players play in league games and miss cup ties then so be it,I didn`t see Clarks injury but he too probably thought he could play on until the second knock.To imply that the manager is putting the players at risk by playing them when they are not fit is ridiculous.They big question from Saturday is …….why does a team who played so well at Raith drop down a couple of gears and struggle at Alloa.Is it complacency or arrogance that stops them getting “up” for the wee teams.


  2. Professional athletes can be quite stubborn while playing through pain. Like you said only MacLeod knows how serious his ankle was prior to the Alloa match – but even Derek Johnstone suggested on the RangersTV broadcast that maybe MacLeod should have skipped the game on Alloa’s artificial surface.

    Clark’s injury was obvious, partly because of timely close-ups from the cameras — who knows what the coaching staff saw from the touchline. But Clark was noticeably holding his shoulder for nearly five minutes…but given the timing toward the end of the half – it’s likely Rangers were waiting to check on Clark at the half. But then he was run over by the Alloa defender & there was no way Clark could continue.

    It’s frustrating to see Rangers spend so much money on a vast squad of players – only to limit their resources to the same 12-13 players. But that’s a discussion for another time…


  3. It looks like when rangers play teams that are at the lower end of the league that they have got the 3 points before a ball is kicked and this could be in line with the previous comment from mr William Laing that they are complacent and very arrogant when it comes to playing teams like Alloa Athletic .


  4. Rangers Report , don`t make the mistake of assuming that Derek Johnstone knows anything that we don`t , you only have to listen to his ramblings during the game to know thats not true .A legend as a player , in fact he was one of my heroes , but a total joke as a pundit.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s